Over the past decades, solid freeform fabrication (SFF) has emerged as the main technology for the production of scaffolds for tissue engineering applications as a result of the architectural versatility. However, certain limitations have also arisen, primarily associated with the available, rather limited range of materials suitable for processing. To overcome these limitations, several research groups have been exploring novel methodologies through which a construct, generated via SFF, is applied as a sacrificial mould for production of the final construct. The technique combines the benefits of SFF techniques in terms of controlled, patient-specific design with a large freedom in material selection associated with conventional scaffold production techniques. Consequently, well-defined 3D scaffolds can be generated in a straightforward manner from previously difficult to print and even "unprintable" materials due to thermomechanical properties that do not match the often strict temperature and pressure requirements for direct rapid prototyping. These include several biomaterials, thermally degradable materials, ceramics and composites. Since it can be combined with conventional pore forming techniques, indirect rapid prototyping (iRP) enables the creation of a hierarchical porosity in the final scaffold with micropores inside the struts. Consequently, scaffolds and implants for applications in both soft and hard tissue regeneration have been reported. In this review, an overview of different iRP strategies and materials are presented from the first reports of the approach at the turn of the century until now.
Liu W, Wang D, Huang J, Wei Y, Xiong J, Zhu W, Duan L, Chen J, Sun R, and Wang D
Materials science & engineering. C, Materials for biological applications [Mater Sci Eng C Mater Biol Appl] 2017 Jan 01; Vol. 70 (Pt 2), pp. 976-982. Date of Electronic Publication: 2016 Apr 12.
Subjects
Animals, Bone and Bones physiology, Cartilage physiology, Humans, Temperature, Tissue Engineering methods, and Tissue Scaffolds chemistry
Materials science & engineering. C, Materials for biological applications [Mater Sci Eng C Mater Biol Appl] 2017 Mar 01; Vol. 72, pp. 433-443. Date of Electronic Publication: 2016 Nov 09.
Materials science & engineering. C, Materials for biological applications [Mater Sci Eng C Mater Biol Appl] 2016 Nov 01; Vol. 68, pp. 651-662. Date of Electronic Publication: 2016 Jun 06.
Subjects
Animals, Humans, Porosity, Rats, Rats, Sprague-Dawley, Biomimetic Materials chemistry, Biomimetic Materials pharmacology, Bone Regeneration drug effects, Ceramics chemistry, Ceramics pharmacology, and Tissue Scaffolds chemistry
Fradique R, Correia TR, Miguel SP, de Sá KD, Figueira DR, Mendonça AG, and Correia IJ
Journal of materials science. Materials in medicine [J Mater Sci Mater Med] 2016 Apr; Vol. 27 (4), pp. 69. Date of Electronic Publication: 2016 Feb 17.
The incidence of bone disorders, whether due to trauma or pathology, has been trending upward with the aging of the worldwide population. The currently available treatments for bone injuries are rather limited, involving mainly bone grafts and implants. A particularly promising approach for bone regeneration uses rapid prototyping (RP) technologies to produce 3D scaffolds with highly controlled structure and orientation, based on computer-aided design models or medical data. Herein, tricalcium phosphate (TCP)/alginate scaffolds were produced using RP and subsequently their physicochemical, mechanical and biological properties were characterized. The results showed that 60/40 of TCP and alginate formulation was able to match the compression and present a similar Young modulus to that of trabecular bone while presenting an adequate biocompatibility. Moreover, the biomineralization ability, roughness and macro and microporosity of scaffolds allowed cell anchoring and proliferation at their surface, as well as cell migration to its interior, processes that are fundamental for osteointegration and bone regeneration.
Tissue engineering. Part C, Methods [Tissue Eng Part C Methods] 2015 Mar; Vol. 21 (3), pp. 229-41. Date of Electronic Publication: 2014 Aug 20.
Subjects
Animals, Cell Differentiation drug effects, Cell Proliferation drug effects, Cell Survival drug effects, Compressive Strength drug effects, Computer-Aided Design, Mesenchymal Stem Cells cytology, Mesenchymal Stem Cells drug effects, Mice, Molecular Weight, NIH 3T3 Cells, Osteogenesis drug effects, Rats, Durapatite pharmacology, Polyesters pharmacology, Polyethylene Glycols pharmacology, Surface-Active Agents pharmacology, Tissue Scaffolds chemistry, and Water chemistry
Abstract
Two major factors hampering the broad use of rapid prototyped biomaterials for tissue engineering applications are the requirement for custom-designed or expensive research-grade three-dimensional (3D) printers and the limited selection of suitable thermoplastic biomaterials exhibiting physical characteristics desired for facile surgical handling and biological properties encouraging tissue integration. Properly designed thermoplastic biodegradable amphiphilic polymers can exhibit hydration-dependent hydrophilicity changes and stiffening behavior, which may be exploited to facilitate the surgical delivery/self-fixation of the scaffold within a physiological tissue environment. Compared to conventional hydrophobic polyesters, they also present significant advantages in blending with hydrophilic osteoconductive minerals with improved interfacial adhesion for bone tissue engineering applications. Here, we demonstrated the excellent blending of biodegradable, amphiphilic poly(D,L-lactic acid)-poly(ethylene glycol)-poly(D,L-lactic acid) (PLA-PEG-PLA) (PELA) triblock co-polymer with hydroxyapatite (HA) and the fabrication of high-quality rapid prototyped 3D macroporous composite scaffolds using an unmodified consumer-grade 3D printer. The rapid prototyped HA-PELA composite scaffolds and the PELA control (without HA) swelled (66% and 44% volume increases, respectively) and stiffened (1.38-fold and 4-fold increases in compressive modulus, respectively) in water. To test the hypothesis that the hydration-induced physical changes can translate into self-fixation properties of the scaffolds within a confined defect, a straightforward in vitro pull-out test was designed to quantify the peak force required to dislodge these scaffolds from a simulated cylindrical defect at dry versus wet states. Consistent with our hypothesis, the peak fixation force measured for the PELA and HA-PELA scaffolds increased 6-fold and 15-fold upon hydration, respectively. Furthermore, we showed that the low-fouling 3D PELA inhibited the attachment of NIH3T3 fibroblasts or bone marrow stromal cells while the HA-PELA readily supported cellular attachment and osteogenic differentiation. Finally, we demonstrated the feasibility of rapid prototyping biphasic PELA/HA-PELA scaffolds for potential guided bone regeneration where an osteoconductive scaffold interior encouraging osteointegration and a nonadhesive surface discouraging fibrous tissue encapsulation is desired. This work demonstrated that by combining facile and readily translatable rapid prototyping approaches with unique biomaterial designs, biodegradable composite scaffolds with well-controlled macroporosities, spatially defined biological microenvironment, and useful handling characteristics can be developed.
Zhongguo xiu fu chong jian wai ke za zhi = Zhongguo xiufu chongjian waike zazhi = Chinese journal of reparative and reconstructive surgery [Zhongguo Xiu Fu Chong Jian Wai Ke Za Zhi] 2014 Mar; Vol. 28 (3), pp. 279-85.
Objective: To review recent literature on three-dimensional (3-D) plotting as a rapid prototyping method for the manufacturing of patient specific biomaterial scaffolds and tissue engineering constructs. Methods: Literature review and description of own recent work. Results: In contrast to many other rapid prototyping technologies which can be used only for the processing of distinct materials, 3-D plotting can be utilized for all pasty biomaterials and therefore opens up many new options for the manufacturing of bi- or multiphasic scaffolds or even tissue engineering constructs, containing e. g. living cells. Conclusion: 3-D plotting is a rapid prototyping technology of growing importance which provides flexibility concerning choice of material and allows integration of sensitive biological components.
Advanced scaffold fabrication techniques such as Rapid Prototyping (RP) are generally recognized to be advantageous over conventional fabrication methods in terms architectural control and reproducibility. Yet, most RP techniques tend to suffer from resolution limitations which result in scaffolds with uncontrollable, random-size pores and low porosity, albeit having interconnected channels which is characteristically present in most RP scaffolds. With the increasing number of studies demonstrating the profound influences of scaffold pore architecture on cell behavior and overall tissue growth, a scaffold fabrication method with sufficient architectural control becomes imperative. The present study demonstrates the use of RP fabrication techniques to create scaffolds having interconnected channels as well as controllable micro-size pores. Adopted from the concepts of porogen leaching and indirect RP techniques, the proposed fabrication method uses monodisperse microspheres to create an ordered, hexagonal closed packed (HCP) array of micro-pores that surrounds the existing channels of the RP scaffold. The pore structure of the scaffold is shaped using a single sacrificial construct which comprises the microspheres and a dissolvable RP mold that were sintered together. As such, the size of pores as well as the channel configuration of the scaffold can be tailored based on the design of the RP mold and the size of microspheres used. The fabrication method developed in this work can be a promising alternative way of preparing scaffolds with customized pore structures that may be required for specific studies concerning cell-scaffold interactions.
Müller WE, Schröder HC, Shen Z, Feng Q, and Wang X
Progress in molecular and subcellular biology [Prog Mol Subcell Biol] 2013; Vol. 54, pp. 235-59.
Subjects
Biocompatible Materials, Biopolymers therapeutic use, Bone and Bones chemistry, Bone and Bones drug effects, Humans, Inorganic Chemicals therapeutic use, Osteocytes drug effects, Osteogenesis drug effects, Porosity, Biopolymers chemistry, Inorganic Chemicals chemistry, Tissue Engineering, and Tissue Scaffolds
Abstract
In recent years, considerable progress has been achieved towards the development of customized scaffold materials, in particular for bone tissue engineering and repair, by the introduction of rapid prototyping or solid freeform fabrication techniques. These new fabrication techniques allow to overcome many problems associated with conventional bone implants, such as inadequate external morphology and internal architecture, porosity and interconnectivity, and low reproducibility. However, the applicability of these new techniques is still hampered by the fact that high processing temperature or a postsintering is often required to increase the mechanical stability of the generated scaffold, as well as a post-processing, i.e., surface modification/functionalization to enhance the biocompatibility of the scaffold or to bind some bioactive component. A solution might be provided by the introduction of novel inorganic biopolymers, biosilica and polyphosphate, which resist harsh conditions applied in the RP chain and are morphogenetically active and do not need supplementation by growth factors/cytokines to stimulate the growth and the differentiation of bone-forming cells.
New manufacturing technologies under the banner of rapid prototyping enable the fabrication of structures close in architecture to biological tissue. In their simplest form, these technologies allow the manufacture of scaffolds upon which cells can grow for later implantation into the body. A more exciting prospect is the printing and patterning in three dimensions of all the components that make up a tissue (cells and matrix materials) to generate structures analogous to tissues; this has been termed bioprinting. Such techniques have opened new areas of research in tissue engineering and regenerative medicine.
Park SH, Park DS, Shin JW, Kang YG, Kim HK, Yoon TR, and Shin JW
Journal of materials science. Materials in medicine [J Mater Sci Mater Med] 2012 Nov; Vol. 23 (11), pp. 2671-8. Date of Electronic Publication: 2012 Sep 19.
Three dimensional tissue engineered scaffolds for the treatment of critical defect have been usually fabricated by salt leaching or gas forming technique. However, it is not easy for cells to penetrate the scaffolds due to the poor interconnectivity of pores. To overcome these current limitations we utilized a rapid prototyping (RP) technique for fabricating tissue engineered scaffolds to treat critical defects. The RP technique resulted in the uniform distribution and systematic connection of pores, which enabled cells to penetrate the scaffold. Two kinds of materials were used. They were poly(ε-caprolactone) (PCL) and poly(D, L-lactic-glycolic acid) (PLGA), where PCL is known to have longer degradation time than PLGA. In vitro tests supported the biocompatibility of the scaffolds. A 12-week animal study involving various examinations of rabbit tibias such as micro-CT and staining showed that both PCL and PLGA resulted in successful bone regeneration. As expected, PLGA degraded faster than PCL, and consequently the tissues generated in the PLGA group were less dense than those in the PCL group. We concluded that slower degradation is preferable in bone tissue engineering, especially when treating critical defects, as mechanical support is needed until full regeneration has occurred.
Medical science monitor : international medical journal of experimental and clinical research [Med Sci Monit] 2012 Nov; Vol. 18 (11), pp. BR435-40.
Subjects
Animals, Biomechanical Phenomena drug effects, Dogs, Fractures, Comminuted diagnostic imaging, Fractures, Comminuted therapy, Male, Radiography, Radius diagnostic imaging, Radius drug effects, Radius pathology, Time Factors, Calcium Phosphates pharmacology, Ceramics pharmacology, Chitosan pharmacology, Fracture Healing drug effects, Fractures, Comminuted pathology, Materials Testing methods, and Tissue Scaffolds chemistry
Abstract
Background: Stabilization and bone healing of fractures in weight-bearing long bones are challenging. This study was conducted to evaluate the effect of a scaffold composed of chitosan fiber and calcium phosphate ceramics (CF/CPC scaffold) on stability and fracture repair in weight-bearing long bones. Material/methods: Comminuted fractures of paired radiuses were created in 36 healthy, mature dogs. The left radius of each dog was classified in the experimental group and treated with CF/CPC scaffold, and the right one was not filled, and was used as a blank control. Of the 12 animals in each group that were killed at week 4, 8, and 12 after the operation, 6 were used for histological analysis, and the other 6 used were for biomechanical studies. Both radiuses from each animal were dissected free and stored for these analyses. All the animals underwent X-ray radiograph pre- and post-operatively. Computer-aided rapid-prototyping technologies were adopted for the fabrication of three-dimensional scaffolds with precise geometric control. Results: X-ray showed that the bone fracture area in the experimental group was filled with callus at week 12 after surgery. Histological examination detected slow resorption of the cement and new bone formation since week 4. At week 12, the scaffold material partially degraded and was still present in all specimens. Mechanical testing revealed that the failure strength of the radiuses treated with CF/CPC scaffolds was about 3 times that of the radiuses without implanted scaffolds. Conclusions: The effect of using CF/CPC scaffold in treating comminuted weight-bearing long bone fractures is satisfactory.
Methods in molecular biology (Clifton, N.J.) [Methods Mol Biol] 2012; Vol. 868, pp. 57-69.
Subjects
Equipment Design, Humans, Time Factors, Tissue Engineering economics, Biocompatible Materials chemistry, Microtechnology instrumentation, Tissue Engineering instrumentation, and Tissue Scaffolds chemistry
Abstract
To create composite synthetic scaffolds with the same degree of complexity and multilevel organization as biological tissue, we need to integrate multilevel biomaterial processing in rapid prototyping systems. The scaffolds then encompass the entire range of properties, which characterize biological tissue. A multilevel microfabrication system, PAM(2), has been developed to address this gap in material processing. It is equipped with different modules, each covering a range of material properties and spatial resolutions. Together, the modules in PAM(2) can be used to realize complex and composite scaffolds for tissue engineering, bringing us a step closer to real clinical applications. This chapter describes the PAM(2) system and discusses some of the practical issues associated with scaffold microfabrication and biomaterial processing.
Engineered scaffolds have been shown to be critical to various tissue engineering applications. This paper presents the development of a novel three-dimensional scaffold made from a mixture of chitosan microspheres (CMs) and poly(L-lactide) by means of the rapid freeze prototyping (RFP) technique. The CMs were used to encapsulate bovine serum albumin (BSA) and improve the scaffold mechanical properties. Experiments to examine the BSA release were carried out; the BSA release could be controlled by adjusting the crosslink degree of the CMs and prolonged after the CMs were embedded into the PLLA scaffolds, while the examination of the mechanical properties of the scaffolds illustrates that they depend on the ratio of CMs to PLLA in the scaffolds as well as the cryogenic temperature used in the RFP fabrication process. The chemical characteristics of the PLLA/chitosan scaffolds were evaluated by Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy. The morphological and pore structure of the scaffolds were also examined by scanning electron microscopy and micro-tomography. The results obtained show that the scaffolds have higher porosity and enhanced pore size distribution compared to those fabricated by the dispensing-based rapid prototyping technique. This study demonstrates that the novel scaffolds have not only enhanced porous structure and mechanical properties but also showed the potential to preserve the bioactivities of the biomolecules and to control the biomolecule distribution and release rate.
Al-Ahmad A, Schubert C, Carvalho C, Thoman Y, Wittmer A, Metzger M, Hellwig E, Swieszkowski W, and Wiedmann-Al-Ahmad M
Journal of biomedical materials research. Part A [J Biomed Mater Res A] 2011 Aug; Vol. 98 (2), pp. 303-11. Date of Electronic Publication: 2011 May 27.
Subjects
Bacteria drug effects, Bacteria ultrastructure, Cell Line, Tumor, Cell Proliferation drug effects, Colony Count, Microbial, Fungi drug effects, Fungi ultrastructure, Humans, Microscopy, Electron, Scanning, Polymers pharmacology, Saliva drug effects, Bacterial Adhesion drug effects, Tissue Engineering methods, and Tissue Scaffolds chemistry
Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers. Part H, Journal of engineering in medicine [Proc Inst Mech Eng H] 2011 Mar; Vol. 225 (3), pp. 315-23.
The tissue engineering scaffolds with three-dimensional porous structure are regarded to be beneficial to facilitate a sufficient supply of nutrients and enable cell ingrowth in bone reconstruction. However, the pores in scaffolds tend to be blocked by the cell ingrowth and result in a restraint of nutrient supply in the further side of the scaffold. An indirect approach of combining the rapid prototyping and gel-casting technique is introduced in this study to fabricate beta-tricalcium phosphate (beta-TCP) scaffolds which not only have interconnected porous structure, but also have a microchannel network inside. The scaffold was designed with customized geometry that matches the defect area, and a double-scale (micropores-microchannel) porous structure inside that is beneficial for cell ingrowth. The scaffolds fabricated have an open, uniform, and interconnected porous architecture with a pore size of 200-400 microm, and posses an internal channel network with a diameter of 600 microm. The porosity was controllable. The compressive yield strength was 4.5 MPa with a porosity of 70 per cent. X-ray diffraction analysis shows that these fabrication processes do not change the crystal structure and chemical composition of beta-TCP. With this technique, it was also possible to fabricate porous scaffolds with desired pore size, porosity, and microchannel, as well as customized geometries by other bioceramics.